My Year Of MacBook Troubles

May 16, 2006

Eagerly buys just-announced MacBook.

May 30

MacBook delivered.

Late June

After about four weeks starts to shut down intermittently. Happens seven times over the next five weeks.

Jul 29

Four shutdowns in a day. Calls Apple. Told to send it to service provider to have logic board replaced.

Aug 17

Macbook returns from repair.

Sep 16

Shutdowns again. More frequently this time. On average 2.8 times per day the next few weeks.

Sep 22

Calls Apple. Logic board needs to be replaced again. There's a new revision that addresses shutdowns. Promised compensation of some kind when my problems are resolved.

Oct 4

MacBook returns from repair.

Oct 6

First shutdown upon sleep due to low battery. Sleep at first seems normal: the display is shut off, the LED lights up, then before it starts to throb the machine shuts down.

Nov 1

Second shutdown upon sleep. Happens three times the next three weeks. During this time, I realize that the screen backlight is weaker, possibly since plastic replaced. Compares with friend's new MacBook to have it confirmed.

Nov 17

Calls Apple. Told to reset PRAM and SMC. Later same day: another shutdown upon sleep. Four more during the coming days.

Nov 20

Calls Apple. Told I will get a new replacement MacBook.

Asks about compensation. Support person says that new Core 2 Duo would be considered a compensation. I refuse to accept this, saying that I would have been compensated if second switch of logic board succeeded, but I wouldn't after having MORE troubles? Support person changes his mind and says we should talk about compensation when my problems are resolved.

Dec 13

New MacBook arrives. Core 2 Duo, yay!

Dec 17

First shutdown upon sleep. Happens a couple times the following days. Also, battery is sometimes reported as not found (crossed-out battery in menu bar). When disconnecting power cable, goes to sleep.

Jan 18, 2007

Calls Apple. Told to reset PRAM and SMC. This seems to make things worse. Calls Apple again. Replacement battery is ordered.

Jan 31

Replacement battery arrives. Seems to work fine. Later same day, shutdown upon sleep.

Feb 1

Calls Apple. Told to replace my 2GB RAM with the shipped 1GB (note: I had shutdowns before upgrading memory), then run Hardware Test, perform Erase & Install and run Apple-only install for two or three days. If problems remain, I'm told, the machine would have to be sent away for repairs.

Feb 2

Hardware Test shows nothing on consecutive runs of both Quick and Extended.

Feb 19

Finally has time to backup everything and do Erase & Install. Later same day: shuts down twice. I charge it just a tad and pull the cord: soon shuts down again.

Feb 20

Calls Apple. Basically told to always plug in the cord or put machine to sleep upon low battery warnings. (Support person claims the warning says this clearly. Which is not the case, it says "If you do not, your computer will go to sleep in a few minutes to preserve the contents of memory".) If I don't it's an error on my part and Apple denies responsibility. Also told to calibrate battery, which I do overnight.

Feb 24–Apr 19

Six shutdowns upon sleep. Twice battery is reported as missing.

May 1

Shutdown upon sleep. Installs battery update.

May 2

Gets MacBook from bag and finds that it is rebooting. Due to battery update?

May 5

Reboots as I close lid. Battery at 55%.

May 15

Shuts down upon sleep. Calls Apple. Long call. First told to reset SMC and PRAM and call back if problem persists. Not satisfied with that answer. Talks to other support person. Checks lots of things. Then told to do Erase & Install and run Apple-only install for a couple of days, to rule out that this is a software issue. Doesn't matter that I did this a couple of months ago. Sigh.

Tomorrow 1 year since placing the order.